Loving to Hate?


I’ve started volunteering as a “Greeter” at a local Planned Parenthood clinic.  Having known women who received healthcare through PP (not only abortions), I’ve been troubled for a long time by reports of the harassment women endure in these difficult moments in their lives.  The fact that this harassment and intimidation is coming from religious people particularly annoys me (I don’t think every person who stands outside a clinic is hateful, yet most are hurtful, even if they have “good intentions”).

I finally had to DO something, even something as small as a few hours a month greeting patients.

All I could say to fellow volunteers after my first shift was:

“This is certainly an education.  More people in the community need to see what’s going on here.”

Imagine this was you, or someone you love:

You’re going to your doctor’s office for an appointment.  Since it’s a personal matter, no one except your physician knows why you’re there (check up?, physical?, prescription?, minor surgery?).  As you drive into the parking lot, your car is immediately surrounded by strangers holding accusing signs and yelling at you.  One is videotaping you, your passenger, your license plate.  Several children hold up signs about dead babies.  You begin to stop, but then see someone in a bright vest waving you into a parking space.  You pull in right in front of a fence.  A volunteer asks if you have an appointment and offers to walk you to the door.

As you get out of the car, someone is looking down on you from over the fence.  With a bullhorn pointed at you, the preacher is shouting at you with Bible verses, calling you a murderer. You try to ignore them as you are ushered away to your appointment.  Inside, as you meet with your physician, you can still hear the aggressive shouting from outside.

When your private visit is over, you walk quickly to your vehicle under the shaming eyes peering over the fence, through the trees, from the driveway. As you drive out the back of the lot, another group stands close to the exit, “praying for you” (or, praying AT you).  Someone stands in the street and approaches the car.  When they thrust a small paper bag toward your window, you try to ignore them.

You drive off, feeling stunned, alone, angry these strangers–men, women, children; pastors and priests–believe they can hurt others in the name of their God.

Imagine it, because it happens–it happens every day, to hundreds of vulnerable people seeking healthcare. . .in America.


btw, the “pastor” with the bullhorn has a judge’s approval for his “free speech.”  He regularly brings his wife and kids of all ages to “protect the unborn children.”


Another volunteer and I wondered:

-Where are the people of faith who could be protecting and assisting the women?

-Where are the believers of any faith who don’t love to hound others or love to hate?

-Why does the city–government at all levels–allow the harassment, permitting the restrictions on personal freedom and privacy?

-Would this be allowed at any doctor’s office, any clinic, any hospital? (I have to ask: how about at any church?)

What we see isn’t “protesting,” it’s straight up harassment, intimidation, and threatening to personal safety.  If volunteers feel threatened, if clinic staff feel threatened, how much more do the women fear for their own safety?


Final note:  Greeting patients with kindness feels very similar to the “compassionate presence” we practiced in chaplaincy.  Now, as a secular person, these small actions are just as valuable and necessary.

Categories: Uncategorized, Women's RightsTags: , ,

8 comments

  1. Thank you for your compassion volunteering to protect women seeking care and understanding. Thank you for sharing your experience with us all!

  2. Dr. Marty Shoemaker's avatar

    Chris you are getting the kind of misguided religious zeal” that is rare where I live in Canada. But I know and read about it in the USA. I know that there are fervent believers all over the world and they excuse their aggression on the case for “protecting life”. Who’s life are they protecting? a clump of cells without consciousness because certainly it is not a fully grown and feeling adult who is in a vulnerable state. We both find this unconscionable and a complete misunderstand and bastardization of the teachings of Jesus. Do they remember the women caught in adultery and being advised to hold your judgement in your typical stone hurdling. Or turn the other cheek, or even anything related to the golden rule and removing the beam in one’s won eye. Here JC is totally humanistic in values. These actions are according to surveys.. one of the biggest reasons WOMEN are leaving the church as youth and vote Democratic. These are very ignorant people who are blinded by their self-righteousness which JC exposed all through his ministry.

    Up here our BC Humanist Assoc. is active exposing “abortion clinics” who hide their religious bias against abortion and set up these sites in our province as if they are “neutral” advisors offering help. It is totally a wolf in sheep’s clothing. We are taking the case to the local legislature to expose these hypocrites who lie to get access to these young women and believe they are “saving” life for every one they intimidate. I loath this kind of hypocrisy. As I am sure you do also.

    Your volunteer work is inspiring and hopefully you will continue to write about this cruelty in your columns. Keep up the great work, Chris.

    • Agreed, Marty, free access to safe healthcare is seriously under threat. The intimidation is unacceptable. Glad you’re confronting the fake clinics there in Canada. So essential to push back hard against these “warriors for God.”

  3. Chris, thank you for standing up to the bullies!

  4. Chris, do you believe abortion should be illegal after a certain number of months of pregnancy and if so where would you put the limit?

Leave a reply to Chris Highland Cancel reply